Losing their marbles? Amal Clooney is advising on getting Elgin Marbles returned to Greece

Before the opening of George Clooney’s movie The Monuments Men, Boris Johnson remarked that George, who said the Elgin Marbles should be returned to Greece,  was showing a rather sketchy knowledge of history.  The Elgin Marbles are a cherished part of the childhood of our Mayor, who would regularly go to the British Museum to marvel at their glories.

georgeamalBoris pointed out the irony of making a movie criticising the looting by Goering and the Nazis of  European art treasures, while advocating the same action, and sarcastically quipped maybe George should get his own marbles restored.

First of all,  Mr. Clooney, the Paris Louvre, the Vatican, Copenhagen, Vienna and Munich also have some parts of the Marbles, not just the British Museum.

Secondly, the removal of the Marbles by Lord Elgin in 1801-5, was with the full permission of the Ottoman authorities It was entirely legal. a fact that seems to have escaped the Hollywood actor and his wife, who is assisting the Greek government is getting the Marbles returned to Greece.  It’s not like Lord Elgin smuggled them out in pieces under his overcoat.

Amal Clooney, George’s new lawyer wife,  is now assisting the Greek government in getting the Marbles back.  This action by Amal  looks like unwarranted interference, and will do nothing to endear George Clooney to the British public.  Let’s hope hope this legal challenge fails!  The movie The Monuments Men, touted as an Oscar contender, about the looting of European art treasures by the Nazis, was a monster flop at the box office.

In February this year,  on the programme London Tonight, historian Bendor Grosvenor said he didn’t always agree with Boris Johnson, but he does on this occasion. How far back do you go? said Bendor.  The Marbles have been in the British Museum for 200 years,   entirely legally. Full details of the history of the Elgin Marbles are here.

Latest 15/10/14  Celebrity lawyer Amal Clooney is now suggesting that the British Museum “swaps“the Elgin Marbles for other artefacts.  Her suggestion leads me to believe the Greeks have no case and legally the Marbles  cannot be returned under duress to Greece.

4 responses to “Losing their marbles? Amal Clooney is advising on getting Elgin Marbles returned to Greece

  1. Given the Ottomans at the time were using the Parthenon as a quarry. Lord Elgin’s actions probably stopped them being reduced to road fill.

    • It was quite legal. Amal Clooney will not endear herself to English party, preening and showing off like she does,, let’s hope she loses this case, would do her good!

  2. Report the history with accuracy. Elgin’s request to the “authorities” was to take a few pieces back to England for study, whereupon he instructed his workers to dismantle the majority of the sculptures–damaging many in the process. As Greece was occupied territory at the time I would hardly call the Ottoman’s acquiescence “legal.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s